The Return of the King Film Discussion (Mythic Mind Movies, ep. 27)
Mythic Mind MoviesEpisode 27
The Return of the King Film Discussion (Mythic Mind Movies, ep. 27)
In this episode
In this episode, we discuss the highs and lows of Peter Jackson’s The Return of the King
Peter Jackson’s The Return of the King is a cinematic finale that keeps much of Tolkien’s spirit on screen (courage when the path is insurmountable, devotion to companions, sacrifice for ordinary domestic life) even while it makes significant, sometimes painful, departures from the book.
In this Mythic Mind Movies conversation, Dr. Andrew Snyder (professor of philosophy and theology) and guests close the Jackson film trilogy. Andrew names it his personal favorite of the three for the force of conclusion, while still granting Fellowship the stronger claim as adaptation. The talk weighs sympathy for what Jackson had to compress, missing Scouring of the Shire, oaths and the Dead, Gollum’s treachery, Frodo and Sam at Mount Doom, and which extended-edition beats help or hurt. Tolkien’s light still springs from the ashes; not every change is forgivable.
Topics include adaptation vs spectacle, eucatastrophe and endings, Denethor and Gondor, the Paths of the Dead, Grey Havens afterglow, and why “all that is gold does not glitter” still lands on film.
Fellows and Companions study every course in the Academy, current and future.
View Membership Options