The Conflict in The Lord of the Rings Is About God, According to Tolkien (Mythic Mind, ep. 199)
Tolkien said the conflict in The Lord of the Rings is about God and his sole right to divine honor. In a lecture given at Huntington University, Andrew follows that claim through the lives of Sauron, Boromir, and Frodo.
Mythic MindEpisode 199
The Conflict in The Lord of the Rings Is About God, According to Tolkien (Mythic Mind, ep. 199)
In this episode
When Tolkien was pressed to say what the conflict at the heart of The Lord of the Rings was finally about, he pointed to God. In a note now published as letter 183 in Humphrey Carpenter’s collection, he said the war is about God and his sole right to divine honor. Sauron desired to be a God-King. The War of the Ring is first a war over worship.
This episode shares a lecture Andrew recently gave at Huntington University on divine honor in The Lord of the Rings, the topic of his forthcoming book, reproduced here with their permission.
He follows that claim through three lives, each brought by the One Ring to a decision about whom they will honor. Sauron began as a gifted servant and fell by loving order more than the One who orders all things. Too ashamed to return for judgment, he poured his own power into the Ring and bound himself to a thing that could be lost. In grasping for power, he was grasped by it. Augustine, in the City of God, describes the same diminishment: the one who tries to be his own light turns from the light that would have made him shine.
Boromir is a valiant man whose virtues, ordered toward the wrong end, became the doorway of his temptation. He wanted to save Gondor and came to call a stolen thing a gift. After he tried to take the Ring from Frodo, he named his sin, spent his life defending the hobbits he had wronged, and received from the true king an honor he could never have taken for himself.
Frodo came to the Ring by inheritance. He accepted a burden he did not choose, learned pity on the road, and failed at the Cracks of Doom. The Ring was unmade through what Tolkien called eucatastrophe, and the mercy Frodo had shown while he was still free saved him when he was no longer free. The honor given him afterward belongs to the king who gives it, and the maimed hand became the title of his glory.
The desire that ruins Sauron is common to every human heart. We may never hold a ring of power, but we are daily offered something that promises to make us masters: the chance to order our small worlds according to our own wisdom, or to secure some genuine good by grasping at the apparently necessary means. True honor is received and given, and it is grounded in God, who alone has the right to divine honor. In the questions that follow the lecture, we turn to Gollum’s part in the unmaking of the Ring, Leaf by Niggle, the problem of orcs, and why Frodo leaves the Shire.
Chapters
- A lecture shared with permission
- Why The Lord of the Rings began to matter
- The conflict is about God
- The Ainulindale and the first discord
- Why honor must be grounded in the good
- Allegory, applicability, and the Ring
- Honor grasped, tested, and given
- Sauron loves order more than the One who orders
- Boromir is tested and rises by confession
- Frodo receives a burden and shows mercy
- Failure at Mount Doom and the meaning of mercy
- What these three lives show us
- Questions from the audience
Choose a chapter to jump the video to that moment.
“It is about God, and His sole right to divine honour.”
Go deeper

Related episode
Tolkien’s Long Defeat: Northern Courage and Christian Hope
Mythic Mind, ep. 75
Watch the episode
Related episode
On Fairy-Stories: Subcreation, Escape, and Consolation
Mythic Mind, ep. 36
Watch the episode
Fellows and Companions study every course in the Academy, current and future.
View Membership Options