Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons and the Grief We Carry (Mythic Mind Games, ep. 57)
In Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, two brothers set out through a fairy tale landscape in search of a cure for their ailing father. Andrew's claim is that the people we have lost can still go forward with us, but after finishing the game he is not convinced it handles grief in a satisfying way.
Mythic Mind GamesEpisode 57
Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons and the Grief We Carry (Mythic Mind Games, ep. 57)
In this episode
Grief is something we have to carry with us. In Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons, two brothers set out through a sprawling European fairy tale landscape in search of a cure for their ailing father. The story begins in tragedy, and Andrew’s claim is that the people we have lost can still go forward with us as we take up the vocations still ahead. He thinks that point is worth making. After finishing the game, he is just not convinced it handles grief in a satisfying way.
In this fellowship conversation, Dr. Andrew Snyder and guests Micah and David talk through the 2013 narrative platformer. Andrew played the remake the night before and came in dissatisfied with how his time had been used. Micah remembered being genuinely hurt by the ending when he first played it. David replayed the original and loves this kind of folk tale, told in a made-up language, that grows more perilous the farther the boys travel from home. They linger on how the two-sided control scheme becomes the storytelling, especially once one half of the controller goes silent, and on a rescue whose meaning only becomes clear later. Andrew still feels the grief is a little ham fisted, as if the story were built around a feeling the designers wanted to produce. Even so, he finds genuine value in the journey through fairyland. Drawing on Tolkien’s essay On Fairy-stories, he says the treasure you can actually bring back is an inward one. The younger brother comes home knowing more of who he is by engaging with death, and is better equipped to engage with life. Along the way they compare the game’s battlefield to Expedition 33 and to the Dead Marshes, sit with the father’s impossible position, and notice the good the brothers did for others even when the cost at home is one no worthwhile father would choose. They close with a grim and beautiful strain of Eastern European romanticism: even in the beautiful there is death, and in the deathly there is something beautiful to be found. Next time they will look at Portal 1 and 2.
Chapters
- Grief is something we must carry with us
- Micah and David join the conversation
- A game that tries to make you feel grief
- A folk tale told as a narrative platformer
- Things in fairy are not what they seem
- When half the controller goes silent
- The battlefield and a grim fairy tale
- The treasure you can bring back from fairyland
- The father, the cost, and what the journey saved
- In the grief there is something beautiful
- Next time: Portal 1 and 2
Choose a chapter to jump the video to that moment.
“Even in the beautiful, there is death and in the deathly, there is something beautiful to be found.”
Go deeper

Related episode
Would You Trade a Lived Life for a Dying Wish? To the Moon
Mythic Mind Games, ep. 56
Watch the episode

Related episode
Expedition 33: Art, Grief, and Sub-Creation
Mythic Mind Games, ep. 41
Watch the episode
Related episode
Video Games as Fairy-Stories: Tolkien and Subcreation
Mythic Mind Games, ep. 1
Watch the episodeFellows and Companions study every course in the Academy, current and future.
View Membership Options